| James Beja | Fr. | Johnstown, S.C. (Strom Thurmond) |
| Caleb Burrow | Fr. | Amherst, N.H. (The Gunnery) |
| Andrew Butte | Fr. | Ft. Worth, Texas (Arlington Heights) |
| Gavin Callies | Fr. | South San Francisco, Calif. (Junipera Serra) |
| Devin Colligan | Fr. | Port Orange, Fla. (Spruce Creek) |
| Andrew Constantino | Fr. | Poughkeepsie, N.Y. (Arlington) |
| William Francis | Fr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. (North Allegheny) |
| James Friedlander | Fr. | Attleboro, Mass. (Attleboro) |
| Michael Hampton | Fr. | Toledo, Ohio (Anthony Wayne) |
| Scott Keelan | Fr. | Cincinnati, Ohio (Moeller) |
| James Kelly | Fr. | Cranbury, N.J. (Peddie) |
| Edward King | Fr. | Kempton Park, South Africa (Arcadia Valley) |
| Steven Krajewski | Fr. | Philadelphia, Pa. (Lower Merion) |
| Stephen Lorenz | Fr. | Escondido, Calif. (Carlsbad Seaside Academy) |
| Michael Martin | Fr. | St. Louis, Mo. (Home school) |
| Christopher Medford | Fr. | Hicksville, N.Y. (Chaminade) |
| Matthew Murphy | Fr. | Chesapeake, Va. (Great Bridge) |
| Richard O'Neill | Fr. | Sewell, N.J. (St. Augustine) |
| Alex Pappalardo, Jr. | Fr. | East Stroudsburg, Pa. (East Stroudsburg) |
| Andrew Parker | Fr. | Erie, Pa. (Cathedral Preparatory School) |
| David Price | Fr. | St. Louis, Mo. (Hazelwood West) |
| Justin Rogers | Fr. | Frederick, Md. (Walkersville) |
| Ian Rubi | Fr. | Fort Worth, Texas (Keller Central) |
| Jason Senko | Fr. | Cincinnati, Ohio (Anderson) |
| Michael Smithson | Fr. | Durham, N.C. (McCallie School) |
| Steven Snow | Fr. | Brecksville, Ohio (Brecksville Broadview) |
| Kevin Spinoza | Fr. | Hurst, Texas (L.D. Bell) |
| Ian Thamm | Fr. | Gillette, Wyo. (Campbell Country) |
| Tucker Witt | Fr. | Gloucester, Va. (Gloucester) |
| Steven Yee | Fr. | Carmel, Ind. (Carmel)
|
