| Rushing Attempts |
| Game | 34 | Richard Engel vs. Army | 11/3/06 |
| | 34 | Matt Sobecki at Army | 11/7/97 |
| Season | 165 | Matt Sobecki | 1997 |
| Career | 290 | Richard Engel | 2004-07 |
| Rushing Yards |
| Game | 263 | Chris Butler at Princeton | 10/11/80 |
| Season | 984 | Matt Sobecki | 1997 |
| Career | 1811 | Chris Butler | 1979-82 |
| Rushing Touchdowns |
| Game | 4 | three times | |
| | | last: Luther Archer vs. Princeton | 9/25/87 |
| Season | 13 | Matt Sobecki | 1997 |
| Career | 24 | Richard Engel | 2004-07 |
| Pass Attempts |
| Game | 52 | Steve Becker at Army | 11/8/68 |
| Season | 211 | Drew McGinly | 1999 |
| Career | 410 | Drew McGinly | 1996-99 |
| Pass Completions |
| Game | 25 | Drew McGinly at Army | 11/12/99 |
| Season | 116 | Drew McGinly | 1999 |
| Career | 215 | Drew McGinly | 1996-99 |
| Passing Yards |
| Game | 318 | James Olsen at Penn | 10/28/05 |
| Season | 1328 | Drew McGinly | 1999 |
| Career | 3017 | Chris Ashinhurst | 2001-03 |
| Passing Touchdowns |
| Game | 5 | James Olsen at Penn | 10/28/05 |
| Season | 15 | James Olsen | 2005 |
| Career | 34 | David Behnke | 1993-96 |
| Receptions |
| Game | 14 | Ryan McDonel at Army | 11/12/99 |
| Season | 39 | Ben Wilson | 1998 |
| Career | 102 | Ben Wilson | 1998-00 |
| Receiving Yards |
| Game | 146 | Ryan McDonel at Army | 11/12/99 |
| Season | 699 | Mike Phillips | 1972 |
| Career | 1368 | Ben Wilson | 1998-00 |
| Receiving Touchdowns |
| Game | 4 | Adam Matthews vs. Penn | 11/1/02 |
| Season | 10 | Theo Williams | 2005 |
| Career | 17 | Ben Wilson | 1998-00 |
| Field Goals Made |
| Game | 3 | five times | |
| | | last: David Reifenberg vs. Army | 9/22/07 |
| Season | 10 | Douglas Wilson | 1985 |
| Career | 14 | Charles Spangler | 1987-89 |
| Extra Points Made |
| Game | 11 | David Reifenberg vs. Princeton | 10/19/07 |
| Season | 37 | David Reifenberg | 2007 |
| Career | 66 | David Reifenberg | 2006-pr. |
| Punts |
| Game | 10 | Jonathan Steier vs. Army | 11/15/98 |
| Season | 36 | Jay Owens | 1997 |
| Career | 62 | Charles Nash | 1999-02 |
| Punt Return Yards |
| Game | 140 | Jordan Foley at Princeton | 10/17/08 |
| Season | 270 | Keith Takabayashi | 1987 |
| Career | 292 | Ed Donahoo | 2000-02 |
| Punt Return Touchdowns |
| Game | 2 | Dave Owens vs. Princeton | 11/6/92 |
| Season | 2 | three times | |
| | | last: Daniel Sweatman | 2002 |
| Career | 2 | three times | |
| | | last: Daniel Sweatman | 2001-02 |
| Kickoff Return Yards |
| Game | 122 | Trevor Garabedian-Prophet vs. Army | 10/2/05 |
| Season | 243 | Jason Martin | 1998 |
| Career | 657 | Trevor Garabedian-Prophet | 2002-05 |
| Kickoff Return Touchdowns |
| Game | 1 | many times | |
| | | last: Trevor Garabedian-Prophet vs. Army | 10/2/05 |
| Season | 1 | many times | |
| | | last: Trevor Garabedian-Prophet | 2005 |
| Career | 3 | Trevor Garabedian-Prophet | 2002-05 |
