Cody Rome '12 Cross Country/Track |  |
"Presented to the midshipman of the graduating class declared by the Association's Athletic Committee to have personally excelled in athletics during his years of varsity competition."
| Year | Name | Class | Sport |
| 1893 | C.S. Bookwalter | '94 | Football/Crew |
| 1884 | A.G. Kavanagh | '94 | Football |
| 1895 | F.D. Karns | '95 | Football/Crew/Track |
| 1896 | L.C. Palmer | '96 | Football/Crew/Track |
| 1897 | A.H. McCarthy | '97 | Football/Crew |
| 1898 | W.B. Tardy | '98 | Football |
| 1899 | S. Gannon | '00 | Football/Crew |
| 1900 | C.T. Wade | '00 | Football/Track |
| 1901 | O.W. Fowler | '01 | Football |
| 1902 | E.S. Land | '02 | Football/Crew |
| 1903 | F.V. McNair | '03 | Football/Baseball/Track |
| 1904 | K. Whiting | '05 | Football/Track |
| 1905 | R.W. Spofford | '06 | Baseball |
| 1906 | R.C. Needham | '07 | Baseball |
| 1907 | J.H. Ingram | '07 | Football/Crew/Track |
| 1908 | W.H. Dague Jr. | '08 | Football/Baseball |
| 1909 | R.E. Jones | '09 | Football/Baseball |
| 1910 | W.D. LaMont | '10 | Gymnastics |
| 1911 | P.V. Weems | '12 | Football/Wrestling/Crew |
| 1912 | J.P. Dalton | '12 | Football/Track |
| 1913 | J.L. Hall | '13 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1914 | J.H. Brown Jr. | '14 | Football/Crew/Track |
| 1915 | H.E. Overesch | '15 | Football/Basketball/Crew |
| 1916 | M.A. Kercher | '16 | Football/Crew |
| 1917 | C.O. Ward | '17 | Football/Wrestling/Crew |
| 1918 | H.M. Martin | '19 | Football/Basketball/Lacrosse |
| 1919 | W.A. Ingram | '20 | Football/Crew |
| 1920 | H. Clark | '21 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1921 | E.C. Ewen | '21 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1922 | C.W. King | '22 | Football/Crew |
| 1923 | I.C. McKee | '24 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1924 | I.C. McKee | '24 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1925 | C.F. Chillingsworth | '25 | Football/Crew |
| 1926 | R.N. Flippin | '26 | Football/Basketball/Lacrosse |
| 1927 | D.T. Eddy | '28 | Football/Crew |
| 1928 | H.F. Ransford | '28 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1929 | T.R. Wilson | '29 | Football/Baseball |
| 1930 | B.F. Swan | '30 | Football/Boxing/Lacrosse |
| 1931 | A.D. Gray | '31 | Football/Crew |
| 1932 | G.W. Underwood | '32 | Football/Track |
| 1933 | W.R. Kane | '33 | Football/Wrestling/Track |
| 1934 | H.Q. Murray | '34 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1935 | F. Borries Jr. | '35 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1936 | L.B. Robertshaw | '36 | Football/Basketball |
| 1937 | W.T. Ingram | '38 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1938 | F.C. Lynch | '38 | Football/Basketball/Track |
| 1939 | L.C. Powell | '39 | Football/Baseball |
| 1940 | A.A. Bergner | '40 | Football/Boxing/Wrestling/Lacrosse |
| 1941 | T.T. Walker | '41 | Track/Cross Country |
| Dec. '41 | S.H. Werner | '42 | Football/Baseball |
| 1942 | W.S. Busik | '43 | Football/Basketball |
| 1943 | G.H. Ochenrider Jr. | '44 | Soccer/Lacrosse |
| 1944 | G.C. Brown Jr. | '45 | Football/Track |
| 1945 | M.W. MacDonald | '46 | Wrestling |
| 1946 | H.R. Duden Jr. | '47 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1947 | J.H. Carrington | '48 | Football/Swimming/Lacrosse |
| 1948 | E.N. Smith | '48 | Football/Wrestling/Track |
| 1949 | J.H. Chambers Jr. | '49 | Lacrosse |
| 1950 | W.F. Hawkins | '50 | Football/Baseball |
| 1951 | J.C. Hunt Jr. | '51 | Football/Wrestling/Lacrosse |
| 1952 | F.C. Davis | '52 | Football/Basketball/Track |
| 1953 | J.S. VanScoyoc | '53 | Basketball/Baseball |
| 1954 | E.G. Stevens | '54 | Crew |
| 1955 | K.R. McCally | '55 | Basketball/Baseball |
| 1956 | Ronald Beagle | '56 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1957 | David Smalley | '57 | Basketball/Baseball |
| 1958 | A.A. Stremic | '58 | Football/Wrestling |
| 1959 | John Meehan | '59 | Soccer |
| 1960 | Karl Rippelmeyer | '60 | Soccer/Lacrosse/Track |
| 1961 | Joseph Bellino | '61 | Football/Baseball |
| 1962 | Greg Mather | '62 | Football/Track |
| 1963 | Don MacLaughlin | '63 | Soccer/Lacrosse |
| 1964 | Thomas Lynch | '64 | Football/Brigade Boxing |
| 1965 | Roger Staubach | '65 | Football/Baseball |
| 1966 | James Lewis | '66 | Soccer/Lacrosse |
| 1967 | John Lawlor Jr. | '67 | Cross Country/Track |
| 1968 | Terrence Murray | '68 | Football/Track/Baseball |
| 1969 | Robert Cowin | '69 | 150# Football/Squash/Tennis |
| 1970 | Joseph Freeman | '70 | Fencing |
| 1971 | John McNallen | '71 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1972 | Lloyd Keaser | '72 | Wrestling |
| 1973 | Eric Swanson | '73 | Gymnastics |
| 1974 | Theodore Bregar | '74 | Track |
| 1975 | Dale Bateman | '75 | Cross Country/Track |
| 1976 | Chester Moeller | '76 | Football |
| 1977 | Daryl Anderson | '77 | Track |
| 1978 | Henry Kuzma | '78 | Basketball |
| 1979 | Jeffrey Johnson | '79 | Soccer/Lacrosse |
| 1980 | Jeffery Colvin | '80 | Track |
| 1981 | Jonathan Wall | '81 | Squash/Tennis |
| 1982 | Edward Meyers | '82 | Football |
| 1983 | Leo Williams | '83 | Track |
| 1984 | Andrew Ponseigo | '84 | Football/Baseball |
| 1985 | Stuart Munsch | '85 | Pistol |
| 1986 | Napoleon McCallum | '85 | Football |
| 1987 | Ronald Harris | '87 | Track |
| 1988 | John Sprenger | '88 | Squash |
| 1989 | Thomas Popp | '89 | Water Polo |
| 1990 | Scott Schleicher | '90 | Wrestling |
| 1991 | Alton Grizzard | '91 | Football |
| 1992 | Luis Nicolao | '92 | Water Polo/Swimming |
| 1993 | Greg Keller | '93 | Cross Country/Track |
| 1994 | Jamieson Slough | '94 | Squash/Lacrosse |
| 1995 | Joseph Hicks | '95 | Wrestling |
| 1996 | Nathan Smith | '96 | Diving |
| 1997 | Brian Walker | '97 | Basketball |
| 1998 | Christopher McCoy | '98 | Football |
| 1999 | Greg Gingeleskie | '99 | Wrestling |
| 2000 | Mickey Jarboe | '00 | Lacrosse |
| 2001 | Adam Borcz | '01 | Lacrosse |
| 2002 | Brian Steckroth | '02 | Soccer |
| 2003 | Aaron Lanzel | '03 | Cross Country/Track |
| 2004 | Craig Candeto | '04 | Baseball/Football |
| 2005 | Matt Albright | '05 | Rifle |
| 2006 | Matt Russell | '06 | Lacrosse |
| 2007 | David Mahoney | '07 | Football |
| 2008 | Matt Stolpinski | '08 | Wrestling |
| 2009 | Mike Mulvey | '09 | Water Polo |
| 2010 | Adam Meyer | '10 | Swimming |
| 2011 | Bryce Saddoris | '11 | Wrestling |
| 2012 | Cody Rome | '12 | Cross Country/Track |
NOTE: "graduating class" requirement added in 1952
