Tommy Phelan '09 Lacrosse |  |
"Presented to the midshipman, male or female, declared by the Association's Athletic Committee to have done the most during the year for the promotion of athletics at the Naval Academy."
| Year | Name | Class | Sport |
| 1893 | C.S. Bookwalter | '94 | Football/Crew |
| 1894 | A.G. Kavanagh | '94 | Football |
| 1895 | F.D. Karns | '95 | Football/Crew/Track |
| 1896 | L.C. Palmer | '96 | Football/Crew/Track |
| 1897 | J.W. Powell | '97 | Football/Crew |
| 1898 | John Halligan Jr. | '98 | Football/Crew |
| 1899 | J.K. Taussig | '99 | Football/Track |
| 1900 | F.D. Berrien | '00 | Football/Track/Baseball |
| 1901 | R. Williams | '01 | Football/Crew |
| 1902 | N.E. Nichols | '02 | Football/Crew |
| 1903 | F.H. Potett | '03 | Football/Baseball |
| 1904 | W.F. Halsey Jr. | '04 | Football |
| 1905 | J.C. Farley | '05 | Football/Crew |
| 1906 | D.L. Howard | '06 | Football |
| 1907 | H.L. Spencer | '07 | Football/Baseball |
| 1908 | A.H. Douglas | '08 | Football/Baseball |
| 1909 | P.W. Northcroft | '09 | Football/Track |
| 1910 | E.D. Wilson | '11 | Football |
| 1911 | Frank Loftin | '11 | Football/Wrestling/Crew |
| 1912 | D.W. Hamilton | '12 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1913 | N.C. Gillette | '13 | Gymnastics |
| 1914 | K.P. Gilcrest | '14 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1915 | R.R. Adams | '15 | Basketball/Baseball |
| 1916 | E.L. Ericsson | '16 | Wrestling/Track |
| 1917 | E.W. Miles | '18 | Football |
| 1918 | E.W. Miles | '18 | Football |
| 1919 | W.A. Ingram | '20 | Football/Crew |
| 1920 | E.D. Graves Jr. | '21 | Football/Crew |
| 1921 | E.P. Moore | '21 | Football/Crew |
| 1922 | E.E. Larson | '22 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1923 | H.A. Bolles | '23 | Football/Crew |
| 1924 | S.G. Barchet | '24 | Football/Baseball |
| 1925 | Fred Billing | '25 | Lacrosse |
| 1926 | W.W. Rutledge | '26 | Track |
| 1927 | T.J. Hamilton | '27 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1928 | E.A. Hannigan | '28 | Football/Baseball |
| 1929 | E.W. Parish Jr. | '29 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1930 | C.W. Hughes | '30 | Football/Wrestling |
| 1931 | R.M. Bowstrom | '31 | Football/Basketball |
| 1932 | M.H. Tuttle | '32 | Football |
| 1933 | C.E. Loughlin | '33 | Basketball/Tennis |
| 1934 | J.J. Waybright | '34 | Football/Track |
| 1935 | W.C. Clark | '35 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1935 | R.E. Dornin | '35 | Football/Basketball/Lacrosse |
| 1936 | C.M. Fellows | '36 | Football/Basketball/Lacrosse |
| 1937 | A.H. Soucek | '37 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1938 | W.T. Ingram | '38 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1939 | L.D. Cooke | '39 | Football/Baseball |
| 1940 | E.S. Gillette Jr. | '40 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1941 | H.A. Harwood | '42 | Football/Baseball |
| Dec. '41 | W.M. Chewning | '42 | Football |
| Dec. '41 | D.D. Blue | '42 | Wrestling/Baseball |
| 1942 | R.J. Zoeller | '43 | Football/Basketball |
| 1943 | A.S. Cameron | '44 | Football/Track |
| 1944 | B.S. Martin | '46 | Football/Track |
| 1945 | D.A. Barksdale | '46 | Football/Boxing/Lacrosse |
| 1946 | D.B. Whitmire | '47 | Football |
| 1947 | K.L. Shugart Jr. | '48 | Basketball |
| 1948 | R.U. Scott | '48 | Football/Track |
| 1949 | J.C. Barrow | '49 | Basketball/Track |
| 1950 | P.J. Ryan | '50 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1951 | W.C. Earl | '51 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1952 | R.P. McDonald | '52 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1953 | D.E. Kniss | '53 | Basketball/Lacrosse |
| 1954 | F.J. Franco Jr. | '54 | Football |
| 1955 | P.S. Blair | '55 | Wrestling |
| 1955 | J.A. Gattuso | '55 | Football/Wrestling |
| 1956 | G.T. Welsh | '56 | Football/Baseball |
| 1957 | A.S. Massimino | '57 | Soccer/Baseball |
| 1958 | J.M. Sendek | '58 | Basketball |
| 1959 | Raymond Wellborn | '59 | Football |
| 1960 | Henry Chiles Jr. | '60 | Lacrosse |
| 1961 | Joseph Bellino | '61 | Football/Baseball |
| 1962 | John Hewitt | '62 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1963 | Roger Staubach | '65 | Football/Basketball/Baseball |
| 1964 | Roger Staubach | '65 | Football/Baseball |
| 1965 | Roger Staubach | '65 | Football/Baseball |
| 1966 | Roger Bickel | '66 | Football |
| 1967 | Richard Mies | '67 | 150# Football/Wrestling |
| 1968 | William Dow | '68 | Football/Basketball |
| 1969 | John Bodine | '69 | Soccer/Lacrosse |
| 1970 | Daniel Pike | '70 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1971 | Lloyd Keaser | '72 | Wrestling |
| 1972 | Charles Voith | '73 | Football/Lacrosse |
| 1973 | Theodore Bregar | '74 | Track |
| 1974 | Cleveland Cooper | '75 | Football |
| 1975 | Myron Hampton | '75 | Basketball |
| 1976 | Chester Moeller | '76 | Football |
| 1977 | Jeffrey Sapp | '77 | Football |
| 1978 | Joseph Guttuso Jr. | '78 | Football |
| 1979 | Phil McConkey | '79 | Football/Outdoor Track |
| 1979 | Kevin Sinnett | '79 | Basketball |
| 1980 | Michael Mullikin | '80 | Baseball |
| 1981 | Theodore Dumbauld | '81 | Football |
| 1982 | Leo Williams | '83 | Track |
| 1983 | Cheryl Dolyniuk | '83 | Swimming/Crew/Volleyball |
| 1984 | Andrew Ponseigo | '84 | Football/Baseball |
| 1985 | Vernon Butler | '86 | Basketball |
| 1986 | David Robinson | '87 | Basketball |
| 1987 | David Robinson | '87 | Basketball |
| 1988 | Scott Kelly | '88 | Wrestling |
| 1989 | Deborah Williams | '90 | Swimming |
| 1990 | Timothy Barkdoll | '90 | Cross Country/Track |
| 1991 | Martha Shue | '91 | Cross Country /Track |
| 1992 | Stacia Johnson | '92 | Swimming |
| 1993 | Greg Keller | '93 | Cross Country /Track |
| 1994 | Jamieson Slough Jr. | '94 | Squash/Lacrosse |
| 1995 | Wesley Cooper | '95 | Basketball |
| 1996 | Joseph Johnson | '96 | Rifle |
| 1997 | Benjamin Fay | '97 | Football |
| 1998 | Hassan Booker | '98 | Basketball |
| 1999 | Michael Ryan | '99 | CC/Track |
| 2000 | Terrence Anderson | '00 | Football |
| 2001 | Tim Strabbing | '01 | Crew |
| 2002 | Mark Conley | '02 | Wrestling |
| 2003 | Craig Candeto | '04 | Football/Baseball |
| 2004 | Billy Hurley | '04 | Golf |
| 2005 | Aaron Polanco | '05 | Football |
| 2006 | Joe Smutz | '06 | Men's Swimming |
| 2007 | Mitch Harris | '08 | Baseball |
| 2008 | Zerbin Singleton | '08 | Football |
| 2009 | Tommy Phelan | '09 | Lacrosse |
